Skip to main content
All articles

Which 3PL Offers the Best Value for Small DTC Brands?

By Menachem ChayempourPublished 6 min read

Sometimes the most useful thing I can tell a small brand is that our network is the wrong place for them. What best value really means at small volume, and what to ask before you sign.

Some of the most useful advice I give small brands is that our network is the wrong place for them.

A premium jewelry brand came to us looking for a 3PL in Los Angeles. Good product, real customers, small volume. We sent the brief to providers in our LA network, and they passed. Not rudely. They told us the volume was too small to be worth setting up.

So I told the brand what I'd tell a friend: a smaller local 3PL outside our network would probably take better care of them for now.

That's not a knock on small 3PLs. To get into our network, a provider needs at least 30,000 square feet and three years in business. That cuts out a lot of good small warehouses, and for a lot of small brands, those are exactly the warehouses they should be talking to.

Best value isn't the lowest rate card

Most small brands compare 3PLs on the pick fee. It's the biggest number on the quote and the easiest one to compare. At small volume, it's usually not where your money goes.

Here's where it goes:

  • The minimum. Many 3PLs have a monthly minimum. If your real fees come in under it, you pay the minimum anyway. At low volume, the minimum often is your bill.
  • Storage. When you don't ship much, inventory sits longer, and storage quietly becomes the biggest line. On one furniture brand's last three months of invoices, storage was 68% of the bill.
  • The fees that aren't the pick fee. Setup or onboarding, a monthly technology or WMS fee, account management, receiving by the carton, packaging, a full pallet charge for a pallet that's half empty.
  • Being the smallest account in the building. This one never shows up on a quote. When the warehouse gets slammed in November, the brand doing 20 times your volume gets the attention first. That's not personal. It's math.

So for a small brand, the best-value 3PL is usually the one where three things are true. You're a meaningful account to them. The minimum fits your slow month, not your best one. And the invoice matches the quote.

The best pricing ask I've seen from a small brand

A food brand spending about $1,500 a month on fulfillment came to us with their pricing requirements already written down:

  • Storage itemized
  • Receiving priced per pallet
  • A one-time charge to sort their opening inventory
  • Case pick and pallet shrink-wrap priced separately
  • No minimums
  • No hidden WMS or setup fees

Then they added one more line: they were open to a longer contract in exchange for better rates.

That last line is the smart part. A small brand doesn't have volume to negotiate with. It has commitment. A 3PL that knows you're staying for a year can afford to treat you differently than one that thinks you might leave next month. If you're going to trade a longer term for something, my opinion is that getting rid of the minimum is usually worth more to a small brand than shaving a few cents off the pick fee. Just make sure the contract still lets you leave if they don't perform. Our guide to 3PL contract length covers the clauses that matter.

Your options at small volume

OptionWorks well whenWatch out for
Ship it yourselfYou can still pack the day's orders in an afternoon, and your time is cheaper than a 3PL's minimumYour time, worse carrier rates, and nobody to cover when you're sick or traveling
A small local 3PLYou want to be an account that matters, and you'd like to be able to walk the floorTheir integrations, what happens if the owner is out, insurance, and whether they can grow with you
A large 3PLYour product is standard, you want strong software, and your volume is growing fastMinimums, support that goes through a ticket queue, and being one of hundreds of brands

None of these is the right answer for everyone. A small brand selling one simple SKU on Shopify has different needs than a small brand with 80 SKUs, heavy boxes and a few wholesale accounts. Fit beats size every time.

What to ask before you sign

  • What's your smallest active client, in orders a month? Where would we rank?
  • What's the monthly minimum in dollars, and which fees count toward it?
  • List every fee that could show up on my invoice that isn't on this quote.
  • How do you bill storage: per pallet, per shelf or bin, per cubic foot? What happens with a half pallet?
  • Who's my contact, and how many other accounts do they handle?
  • What happens to my orders during your peak?
  • Run last month's real orders through your rate card and give me the total.

That last one is the question that matters most. A rate card is a menu. The total from your actual month is the bill. Our fulfillment cost calculator can help you rough out the numbers before you ask, and how to compare 3PL quotes walks through checking them line by line.

When you're too early

To be fair, sometimes the right 3PL for a small brand is no 3PL yet. If most of your fulfillment bill would be the minimum, you're probably early. Keep shipping yourself, tighten up your packaging and carrier rates, and come back when the volume is there.

The jewelry brand didn't need a bigger warehouse. It needed one that would pick up the phone. When their volume grows, the bigger buildings will still be there, and they'll be a lot more interested.

Pick the 3PL that would notice if you left.

Frequently asked questions

Which 3PL offers the best value for small DTC brands? Usually a 3PL where you're a meaningful account, the minimum fits your slowest month, and the invoice matches the quote. For many small brands that's a smaller regional or local 3PL, not the biggest name. Compare on the total for one real month of your orders, not on the pick fee.

Are there 3PLs with no minimums? Yes, some don't charge one, and some will drop it in exchange for a longer contract. Ask what you give up in return, like higher per-order rates or a longer notice period.

How many orders a month do I need before using a 3PL? There's no single number. A better test: if most of your 3PL bill would be the monthly minimum, you're probably early. If packing orders is taking time you should be spending on sales, you're probably ready.

How much does a 3PL cost for a small business? It depends on your order count, units per order, box sizes, how much inventory you store and where your customers are. The main lines are receiving, storage, pick and pack, packaging, postage and any monthly minimum. Get a quote on a real month of your orders to know your number.

Should a small brand use a big 3PL or a local one? A local or regional 3PL often gives a small brand more attention and more flexibility. A large 3PL often has better software and more locations. Pick based on what your product and channels need, and on where you'd rank among their clients.

Not sure where you fit?

Tell us what you ship. If you fit our network, we'll match you with vetted 3PLs and get every quote on the same line items. If you're too small for it right now, we'll tell you that too, the same way we told the jewelry brand. Providers pay our fee. Brands put down a refundable deposit so we only take on serious searches, and when you sign, we pass it to your 3PL as a credit on your first invoice.

Never miss a week of logistics intel

Weekly analysis on 3PL capacity, freight rates, and fulfillment costs, read by 21,000 logistics professionals.

Ready to find the right fit?

Tell us your requirements. We do the vetting. You only talk to providers worth your time.

Find your 3PL match