Skip to main content
All articles

Which 3PL Should You Use for B2B Ecommerce (and DTC)?

By Menachem ChayempourPublished 7 min read

A beverage brand said their B2B was one LTL shipment a month. Their data said 62% of their cases went to businesses by parcel. How to figure out which 3PL fits the B2B you actually have.

A beverage brand told us their B2B was simple. About one LTL shipment a month. Everything else was DTC.

Then they sent us three months of shipment data.

47% of their boxes went to business addresses, and those boxes carried 62% of their cases. Their wholesale wasn't one pallet a month. It was case packs going out by parcel to businesses all month long.

If we'd sent their RFP out on the brief alone, every 3PL would have priced a DTC operation with a little LTL on the side. The quotes would have looked clean. They just wouldn't have been quotes for this brand.

It happens more than you'd think. A toy brand's intake form said wholesale ships LTL, one to five pallets at a time. Their order export showed one LTL shipment in three months. Their wholesale was a handful of orders a month that came in by email.

Neither brand was hiding anything. They described B2B the way they think about it, not the way it actually ships. And "which 3PL should I use for B2B ecommerce?" doesn't have an answer until you know which kind of B2B you have.

"B2B" is at least four different jobs

When a brand says B2B, they usually mean one or more of these. Each one needs something different from a warehouse.

Type of B2BWhat it looks likeWhat the 3PL needsAsk them
Pallets to distribution centersFull pallets or LTL to retailer or distributor DCs, shipped against a PODock doors, clean pallet builds, LTL carriers, appointment scheduling"How many LTL appointments do you book a week, and who books the freight?"
Case packs by parcel1 to 10 cases at a time to stores, gyms, offices, cafesCase pick, case labels, good parcel rates on heavy boxes"What do you charge per case picked, and what's your rate on a 20 to 40 lb box?"
Big-box retail complianceOrders over EDI, strict routing guides, labels and ship windowsAn EDI connection, UCC-128 labels, VICS bills of lading, people who actually read routing guides"Which retailers are you live with on EDI right now?"
Amazon and Walmart replenishmentFBA or WFS shipments into fulfillment centersPrep, FNSKU labels, carton and pallet labels, appointment rules"How many FBA shipments did you send last month?"

A 3PL that's great at one of these can be average at the next. The warehouse that ships thousands of single-unit Shopify orders a day may have never built a pallet to a grocery DC's routing guide. The warehouse that lives on big-box compliance may treat your Shopify orders as something to get to after the retail trucks leave.

No EDI doesn't mean no compliance

A food brand we're working with ships 5 to 7 B2B orders a month, 70 to 100 cases each, to grocery DCs and distributors. Purchase orders come in by email and PDF. No EDI.

On paper, that's easy B2B. In practice, those orders come with routing guides and delivery appointments. Miss the appointment and the DC can turn the truck away. Build the pallet wrong and it can come back.

So when you tell a 3PL "we don't need EDI," also tell them what you do need. Send the routing guide with the RFQ. A good 3PL will read it and tell you what it costs to follow. A bad one will say "no problem" and find out on the first order.

Where one 3PL doing both goes wrong

Now look, plenty of 3PLs run B2B and DTC out of the same building and do it well. For most brands one warehouse is simpler and cheaper than two. But these are the spots where it breaks:

  • Inventory gets fought over. A big wholesale PO and a DTC promo hit the same week. Who decides which channel gets the last 300 units? If you didn't decide ahead of time, the warehouse decides for you.
  • Cutoffs are different. DTC wants same-day. A retail order might need to ship inside a set window, not early and not late.
  • Billing is different. DTC is priced per order and per unit. B2B is per case, per pallet, per label, sometimes per appointment. If a quote only prices your DTC carefully, the B2B lines are where the surprises are.
  • Labor is different. Picking single units is a different job than picking full cases and building a pallet that survives a truck. Ask who on the floor handles your B2B orders.
  • Chargebacks. Retailers charge for late, wrong or mislabeled shipments. Read the contract for who pays when the 3PL causes one.

How to figure out which 3PL fits

1⃣ Pull three months of shipments, not orders. Box by box if you can. Tag each one as residential, business, retailer DC, Amazon, or freight.

2⃣ Count it two ways. By boxes, and by cases or units. The beverage brand's business shipments were under half the boxes but most of the cases. The share that drives your labor isn't always the share that drives your order count.

3⃣ Write down every B2B type you actually have, from the table above, with a real monthly number next to each one.

4⃣ Send the documents with the RFQ. Routing guides, retailer vendor manuals, your Amazon prep requirements. Have every 3PL price the same month the same way. Our 3PL RFQ guide covers how to build that month, and how to compare 3PL quotes covers reading what comes back.

5⃣ Ask for proof on the B2B side. A current client shipping to the same kind of buyer you ship to. A retailer they're live with. A reference you can call.

6⃣ Ask what share of their outbound is B2B. If you'd be their only wholesale account, you're not a client. You're their training program.

When two 3PLs make more sense

Sometimes the honest answer is two warehouses. If your wholesale is pallet-heavy retail compliance and your DTC is high volume and integration-heavy, one building can end up average at both. Two specialists can cost less than one generalist covering for its gaps, even after you pay to keep inventory in two places.

But don't start there. Start with the data and let the shipment mix tell you.

The beverage brand still needs a 3PL that's good at DTC. It also needs one that can pick a lot of cases every day and ship them by parcel at a rate that makes sense. That's a different search than the one their brief described, and it would have been easy to run the wrong one.

Your B2B is whatever your shipment data says it is.

Frequently asked questions

Which 3PL should I use for B2B ecommerce? One that's already doing your type of B2B for other clients today. Pallets to DCs, case packs by parcel, big-box EDI and Amazon replenishment are different jobs. Figure out which ones you have from your shipment data, then ask each 3PL for a current client and a reference doing the same thing.

Can one 3PL handle both B2B and DTC? Yes, and most brands should start with one. Check how they split inventory between channels, their cutoffs for each, how they bill case and pallet work, and who on the floor handles your wholesale orders.

Do I need a 3PL with EDI? Only if your retailers require it. Many grocery and specialty buyers send purchase orders by email, but they still have routing guides, labels and delivery appointments. Send those documents to every 3PL you're considering.

What's the difference between B2B and DTC fulfillment? DTC ships individual orders to people's homes and is priced per order and per unit. B2B ships cases or pallets to businesses and retailers, is priced per case, pallet or label, and usually comes with the retailer's rules for labels, paperwork and delivery windows.

How do 3PLs charge for B2B orders? Usually per case picked, per pallet built and wrapped, per label, and sometimes per order or per appointment. Freight is either booked by the 3PL and passed through, or booked by you. Ask for these lines on the quote, not only the DTC pick fee.

What's the best 3PL for wholesale to retail stores? For case packs to independent stores, look for strong case pick and good parcel rates on heavy boxes. For shipments into retailer DCs, look for LTL experience and a team that works from routing guides every day.

Shipping both?

Tell us what you ship, and send the shipment data, not only the summary. We'll find the B2B your brief left out and match you with vetted 3PLs that already do that kind of work. Providers pay our fee. Brands put down a refundable deposit so we only take on serious searches, and when you sign, we pass it to your 3PL as a credit on your first invoice.

Never miss a week of logistics intel

Weekly analysis on 3PL capacity, freight rates, and fulfillment costs, read by 21,000 logistics professionals.

Ready to find the right fit?

Tell us your requirements. We do the vetting. You only talk to providers worth your time.

Find your 3PL match